"Creating safe spaces for Muslim young people to explore personal,
social, spiritual and political choices"


Friday Thoughts 39



Those who struggle for Our sake - We shall guide them on Our paths, 
and God is with those who do good. (Surah 29:69)


Among the events that are remembered in the month of Ramadan is the Battle of Badr. Contemporaries perceived it as a miracle when a small 
band of three hundred Muslims from Madinah, some of them recently 
immigrated and hardly settled yet, unprepared for war and 
insufficiently armed but fighting for their existence, were able to defeat a thousand well-equipped Quraish from Makkah.


People frequently think of battles in the literal sense when they 
come across the term jihçd. For some Muslims this is assocoated with a romantic sense of chivalry or doubtful heroism; others connect it 
with "fire and sword" or extreme religious zeal and expansionism that 
are perceived as a direct contrast both to modern pluralist values 
and to ideals of gentleness, justice and harmony. The term itself has 
often been shamefully misused for aggressive purposes and even crimes 
in the name of religion and mistranslated as "Holy War". Its real
meaning is struggle, effort in a very general sense.


In fact, fighting for survival, as in the Battle of Badr, may be a 
necessary effort and included in the wide range of meanings of
jihād. But it is only one effort among many and as such termed qitāl, defense, while the term harb, war, anger, aggression, is not used in 
this context and, in Qur'anic usage, considered negative and 
destructive. Al-Harb al-muqaddasa, "Holy War", is an oxymoron. In 
Islam, self-defense, qitāl, is legitimate and permitted, provided 
that certain limits are respected, like the prohibition to use 
excessive means and to harm non-combatants, while every possibility 
to break the cycle of violence is to be utilized and every offer for 
ceasefire and negotiations is to be taken seriously. After all, fighting for peace is a contradiction in terms, and peace is the 
ultimate aim we are striving for.


On the other hand, many efforts that are included in the term jihād get far less attention in the public discourse. There is, for 
example, the effort to work for a legitimate, halal, income in order 
to support oneself and one's family and to enable one's children to 
get a decent education. There is the effort to acquire knowledge that 
is useful both for practical purposes, material welfare, and 
spiritual progress. There is the struggle to coping with the 
challenges of everyday life like trying to overcome obstacles to 
one's legitimate interests, to be patient and tolerant with fellow 
human beings who seem to make life difficult, or to deal with setbacks, bad luck and frustration.


The latter touches on another element: struggling with one's own 
impulses and inclinations. This might be much harder than the 
struggle with external forces. External struggle is supported and 
even prompted by our natural instinct of self-preservation against 
everything that is perceived as a threat and for everything that is 
perceived as beneficial. If religion were about asserting one's own identity profile or to defend and promote group or institutional interests, we could do without it altogether because this is already 
taken care of by our individual and collective instinct of self-
preservation. On the contrary: our instincts can easily get out of 
control unless they are checked either by insurmountable external
limits or by the voice of conscience that tells us when it is enough 
and how to differentiate between legitimate and exaggerated
interests, between real and imagined threats. Heeding the voice of 
conscience is what religion is about. That is why principles, rules
and methods like prayer, meditation, and fasting are taught by our 
holy scriptures. That is why great scholars like al-Ghazzali devote 
volumes to analyzing and controlling the motives behind our actions,
to identify and deal with impulses like avarice, envy, anger, hatred, 
pride, miserliness and to train oneself to become more understanding,
considerate and loving to other people. That is why once when the 
people came back home after one of the contemporary battles, the 
Prophet reportedly said, "You have come from the lesser jihād to the Greater Jihād." It is the Greater Jihād because it is a lifelong 


I think this is what is emphasized in the statement, "Those who
struggle for Our sake - We shall guide them on Our paths." One reason is that it was revealed in Makkah before the hijra, before the word
jihād became associated with armed struggle. The other one is the 
wording in the Arabic: literally, it says, "Those who struggle in Us": the meaning points beyond any external struggle for God's sake to the unremitting, patient effort to work on one's own character and 
one's relationship with one's fellow human being and the rest of 
creation in the presence of the Creator.


In fact, the two aspects of external and internal struggle are not 
separate. Being engaged in the "Greater Jihād" changes the quality 
and direction of the "lesser jihād". This is what is pointed out by
the Prophet's statement, "The greatest jihād is a just word in front 
of an unjust ruler." Among the examples we are presented in the 
Qur'an there is, as "a model for those who have faith, Pharaoh's 
wife", traditionally called Assia, who takes a consicerable risk 
confronting her tyrannical husband with the decision to save Moses' 
life and to bring him up; and there is Moses himself as a grown man,
reminding Pharaoh that he is not the "highest lord" but accountable 
to the Master of the Universe, and demanding the release of the 
enslaved Children of Israel. Among the more well-known examples in 
Muslim history there is the Prophet's granddaughter Zaynab whose courageous appeal before Yazīd, the ruler who had killed her brother 
Husayn and many other family members, saved her nephew Zayn al-
'Ābidin's life and preserved the values they stood for.


Such courage of one's convictions implies both conquering one's own 
fears and standing up against injustice. It means discipline and conscientiousness - to which fasting is one of the means. It shows human greatness and promotes life, freedom, justice, respect and 
dignity. It is an invaluable tool in our efforts for reconciliation, understanding and peace. It is in this sense that I call everyone for
a true jihād and wish all of you a successful remaining Ramadan and a 
happy 'Īd al-Fitr.




(c) Halima Krausen, 2007